Personal tools
You are here: Home Research Archived Research Modules Dissertation (Sept09) Conversations Conversation 7 - Results, analysis and discussion

Conversation 7 - Results, analysis and discussion

This is a summary of what to do in the Results, Evidence, Analysis, Discussion and Impact Sections of your dissertation.

By now you should be clear about what data you will be collecting and have started to collect some.


The next stages are: -
•    The Evidence  - this is a portrait, display and description of your evidence
•    The Analysis of evidence - this is in the form of a discussion
•    Impact  - this is an account of

A. What you have learned

B. What difference you have made.

Portraying the Evidence       

You will mainly be using text to describe the data you have collected. Also consider using:

o    Charts

o    Diagrams

The Analysis of Evidence

 

Guidance on the process of analysis is provided Here:

 

This outlines the description (which you should have in the methods section for the “Steps to analysing the data” including:

    Collating

    Immersion

    Coding

    Sorting

    Hypothesis testing

    Pattern identification.

 

You should evaluate - you need to show weighing up of the research.

    Sources of bias

    Descriptive Validity

    Explanatory Validity

    Reliability of the results

 

You should also

Weigh up the evidence

Verify the evidence

 

Impact

You need to systematically describe the impact of your scholarship:

Use Kirkpatrick’s classification (From http://www.businessballs.com/kirkpatricklearningevaluationmodel.htm)

 

•    Your learning: What new perspectives have been revealed to you?

•    Your practice: Changes to what you do

•    The learning experience of pupils: How has what pupils do and/or experienced changed?

•    The learning outcomes of pupils: To what extent have the standards achieved by pupils been affected?

•    The practice of colleagues or of the school.

 

 

Please  let us know how things are  by commenting and sharing your findings here.
Document Actions

Analysis

Posted by Ian at Jun 15, 2010 04:12 PM
The new ideas about analysing ideology are found at
http://midwhebonline.org.uk/[…]/core-5-analysing-data


Is your research really contributing to the big issues of equality, justice, etc?


Does it fit into an ideology such as modernism (making the machine work efficiently or neo liberalism (making the market work)?

How things are going

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 09, 2010 07:35 AM
Things are going ok, I am now on the final stage of my dissertation and analysing my results, this should be done soon and handed in.

How things are going

Posted by Ian at Jul 09, 2010 08:26 AM
Good

How things are going

Posted by Ian at Jul 09, 2010 08:27 AM
Are you considering the ideology behind saying things are better? (as mentioned above?)

How things are going

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 09, 2010 08:33 AM
What do you mean?

Harvard

Posted by Ian at Jul 09, 2010 08:30 AM
Have you any problems with Harvard referencing?

Guide is at http://midwhebonline.org.uk/[…]/view?searchterm=Harvard

Harvard

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 09, 2010 08:33 AM
Im pretty good with this and have used harvard referencing.

6000 Words

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 09, 2010 08:34 AM
Hi Ian

Am I still working towards 6000 words for this section, because there seems to be plenty to cover.

Thanks

6000 Words

Posted by Ian at Jul 09, 2010 09:16 AM
Sounds reasonable:-

Does this conform to the suggested framework found at

http://midwhebonline.org.uk/research/dissertationsept09 (left column)

and specifiacally
http://midwhebonline.org.uk/[…]/dissertation-structure


Your independence and autonomy may lead you to a different pattern

6000 Words

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 09, 2010 10:59 AM
Yes it certainly does, thank you for the swift reply i feel better about this already.

Errors I have seen

Posted by Ian at Jul 12, 2010 01:02 PM
Please describe all the data first refernicng where your information comes from (eg Interview Number 1), (Survey) etc

Don't leap to conjecture until your explanation and analysis. This might be backed up by reference to the literture as what you would or would not expect.

data collection

Posted by marion craven at Jul 17, 2010 03:10 PM
Should I put the transcripts into the appendix?

Trying my best to write up the sections. However I know where it is all going. I just need time!

Interestingly the impact of the project is different than I thought it would be (i.e. rolling it out in school next term) but that is because I have been made redundant and the parents are not happy. Initially I thought I was going to have difficulty getting parents interested in their child's learning, now they don't want me to leave. The confidence that the parents have gained has been reflected in their actions to the governing body, MP and the newspapers.

Marion

data collection

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 22, 2010 08:28 AM
Hi Marion

Yes all transcipts and raw data collected are to go in the appendix.

Huseyin

data collection

Posted by marion craven at Jul 22, 2010 05:36 PM
Dear Huseyin,

Thanks for your answer - will do as you suggest. Did any thing interesting come out of your project?

I am just writing up my methodology - I read in an earlier conversation you asked about how to go about writing the methodology but then implied you had worked it out. Did you just follow the list in the disseration guide?

How near are you to finishing? I haven't heard from any one else.

Marion

data collection

Posted by Huseyin at Jul 24, 2010 09:27 AM
Hi Marion

Yes I follwed it loosely. Its not 100% by he book as they say. My research section has me explaining what i plan to carry out, Ethincs and flaws in each approach. I sent this over to one of the mentors and they said it was ok. So i gathered it was fine.

I have now completed the Dissertation...well only 200 words or so more and its done. It was targetting the curriculum and the specific section that says "students will emerge from school as confident ICT users ready to be integrated into society" The truth is that the students are not being prepared as well for this task in some subjects. That has been my discovery. I will have it bound and you are most welcome to it :) after all that is why i have written it.

data collection

Posted by marion craven at Jul 26, 2010 04:31 PM
lucky you - I would love to read it.

I am trying my best to write the methodology section - something I had read and carried out in practice. But I run out of time to write it up, as much of my time was taken up applying for jobs. it was more important to collect my data in time.

I have asked for an extension but still need to get as much done as possible other wise I will totally on my own. therefore i am pushing a draft through in the next few weeks and then come back to it for a complete over haul.

Thank you for your support - have a good holiday

marion