Personal tools
You are here: Home MA Inclusive Education Archived Materials Working Together

Working Together

This is a hotseat discussion

Working Together - Speech and Language Therapy and Mainstream Teachers

 



 Lucie Cox

Lucie Cox

Specialist Speech and Language Therapist

Mainstream Primary Schools


I graduated as a Speech and Language Therapist in 2004 and have since then been working in the London borough of Hackney in London. I work in Mainstream Primary Schools with children with a range of Speech, Language and Communication Needs. The age range I work with is from 3 to 11 year olds.




Useful Links to External Sites




The Targets and Activities project (TAP) website
 

ELKLAN Language builders  and Secondary Language Builders

ICAN Primary Talk 

The Communication Cook book 

Targeting Talk  
























Before I give you an outline of the focus of my work in schools I would like to de-mystify the role of the Speech and Language Therapist (SLT).

When SLTs talk about:
➢    ‘Speech’  - they mean articulation of speech sounds. Children typically develop the ability to say certain speech sounds in a specific developmental order. Children can have a delay in their speech sound development in isolation of other difficulties, a speech sound disorder in isolation, or speech sound difficulties in the context of broader language and communication difficulties or learning difficulties.
➢    ‘Language’  - they mean the ability to understand what is being said and the ability to use language to communicate. This may be a specific difficulty with language (learning language in a delayed or disordered way) in isolation, or language difficulties in the context of a broader communication or learning difficulty. Language here can mean both spoken language and signs.
➢    ‘Communication’ – they mean all the other things we do when we communicate. For example social skills/non-verbal communication i.e. turn taking in conversation, looking at the person you are communicating with, active listening skills.

There are essentially 3 parts to the focus of my work in schools
➢    Universal work (National Curriculum equivalent of Wave 1) – embedding good communication practise throughout the schools I work in (for example through whole school training, coffee mornings for parents).
➢    Targeted work – (National Curriculum equivalent of Wave 2) – supporting the school in setting up and embedding specific input for targetted groups of children (for example through modelling language groups, social skills groups, groups around transition from Year 6 to Year 7).
➢    Specialist work – (National Curriculum equivalent of Wave 3) supporting schools to work with children who need a more intensive and specialist programmme of work to access the curriculum or communicate to the best of their ability (for example children with Speech sound difficulties, children on the Autistic Spectrum, children with Learning Difficulties)


The government recently commissioned John Bercow to Review Speech, Language and Communication services in England and Wales. This report stressed how crucial communication development is for children and the importance of services working together to ensure a joined up approach.  The report concluded that:

‘Although there are some skilled professionals and very good facilities (with pockets of excellence Hackney being one of them), the overall position is highly unsatisfactory.
 
Access to information and services is often poor, services themselves are very mixed, continuity across the age range is lacking, effective joint working between the health and education services is rare and there is something of a postcode lottery across the country.’

Current understanding of good practice that improves childrens’ language and communication skills includes:
➢    Clear roles – involving all relevant individuals
➢    Joint working and good communication between services
➢    Contextualised learning which ensures relevance to each child
➢    Systematic teaching to overcome difficulties in language processing
➢    Equity of provision

However emerging evidence is that if pupils’ language levels are to improve it is not sufficient to expose them to a language rich environment but that much more curriculum based but tailored intervention is required.

 

 

Questions to consider.

 

➢    How can we ensure that Language and Communication needs become central to the wider curriculum?

 

➢    One of the Inclusion Development Plan’s current topics of focus is Speech, Language and Communication development.

   Has your school started to incorporate this into their development?

   plan? If so has it made a difference to classroom practice and how?

   is it impacting on curriculum delivery?  If not what do you think your school needs to do?

 

➢    The evidence suggests that making sufficient time for language activities will promote pupils’ language output.

 

➢    Have you any examples of schools prioritising language activities?

➢    Have you any examples of communication friendly classrooms?

➢    Can you provide examples of activities that promote language development that can permeate good teaching for all children?

 

 

Useful links to support your thinking:

 

The Language Support model for Teachers by Elspeth McCartney provides a comprehensive range of ideas for teachers who are working with Speech and Language Therapists to support children in mainstream with SLCN

 

 

 

Document Actions

Welcome

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 15, 2009 03:20 PM
Hello Lucy,
It is nice to meet you. I am looking forward to learning from you and exchanging ideas on Speech and Language. Though it is not exactly related, but I found my experience in esl and the challenges we face in some things are similar to working with pupils who have speech and language issues. I am sure in regards to learning difficulties their would be added concerns and more indepth focuses to learning.
In the similarity, I found, for incorporating SLT into the curriculum like dramatic arts and sharing (giving a little speach about an interest or item the pupil likes) has been successful for building confidence, skill, learning through actions and viusuals, and also bringing in something of their own to motivate the pupil to try. I found that after some time they enjoy the lessons and remember more of what is being taught. Story telling, amd music has also been a great tool to help them organize their thoughts, words and sentences.
These are approaches I've used for my students in a highly multicultural classroom and mixed abilities.
I do also find that story cards and visual posters are great to incorporate into social studies, like when we discuss emotions, and manners, topics like that. (I'm not sure what the UK calls these lessons)
I also found games helpful, like Mother may I, simon says, and What's the time mr. Wolf and others.

Would teachers and administrators consider adding some multiple intelligences into the teaching approaches?
Another interesting observation was that I found music like rythm and chants and tones helpful for some students.

I am eager to hear your ideas and approaches and what you recommend.
all the best,
Jessica

Welcome

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 15, 2009 03:22 PM
Hello Lucy,
It is nice to meet you. I am looking forward to learning from you and exchanging ideas on Speech and Language. Though it is not exactly related, but I found my experience in esl and the challenges we face in some things are similar to working with pupils who have speech and language issues. I am sure in regards to learning difficulties their would be added concerns and more indepth focuses to learning.
In the similarity, I found, for incorporating SLT into the curriculum, dramatic arts and sharing (giving a little speach about an interest or item the pupil likes) has been successful for building confidence, skill, learning through actions and viusuals, and also bringing in something of their own to motivate the pupil to try. I found that after some time they enjoy the lessons and remember more of what is being taught. Story telling, amd music has also been a great tool to help them organize their thoughts, words and sentences.
These are approaches I've used for my students in a highly multicultural classroom and mixed abilities.
I do also find that story cards and visual posters are great to incorporate into social studies, like when we discuss emotions, and manners, topics like that. (I'm not sure what the UK calls these lessons)
I also found games helpful, like Mother may I, simon says, and What's the time mr. Wolf and others.

Would teachers and administrators consider adding some multiple intelligences into the teaching approaches?
Another interesting observation was that I found music like rythm and chants and tones helpful for some students.

I am eager to hear your ideas and approaches and what you recommend.
all the best,
Jessica

Welcome

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 15, 2009 03:25 PM
Hello Lucy,
It is nice to meet you. I am looking forward to learning from you and exchanging ideas on Speech and Language. Though it is not exactly related, but I found my experience in esl and the challenges we face in some things are similar to working with pupils who have speech and language issues. I am sure in regards to learning difficulties their would be added concerns and more indepth focuses to learning.
In the similarity, I found, for incorporating SLT into the curriculum, dramatic arts and sharing (giving a little speach about an interest or item the pupil likes) has been successful for building confidence, skill,and learning through actions with the use of viusuals enabled them to retain information better.Also, bringing in something of their own to motivate the pupil to try to communicate. I found that after some time they enjoy the lessons and remember more of what is being taught. Story telling, amd music has also been a great tool to help them organize their thoughts, words and sentences.
These are approaches I've used for my students in a highly multicultural classroom and mixed abilities.
I do also find that story cards and visual posters are great to incorporate into social studies, like when we discuss emotions, and manners, topics like that. (I'm not sure what the UK calls these lessons)
I also found games helpful, like Mother may I, simon says, and What's the time mr. Wolf and others.

Would teachers and administrators consider adding some multiple intelligences into the teaching approaches?
Another interesting observation was that I found music like rythm and chants and tones helpful for some students.

I am eager to hear your ideas and approaches and what you recommend.
all the best,
Jessica

I am ready to learning more

Posted by Hyacinth Rose-Manners at Jun 15, 2009 06:39 PM
Hi Lucy,

SLT I believe is to be understood by all teachers in order to include it into our curriculum with knowledge we can make more informed suggestions for inclusion. I must start with my own SL difficulties, I am Dyslexic and has difficulties with polysyllabic words, I need to take it slowly both in pronouncation(and spelling), but sometimes I know what I should say but is not saying it needs sorting out at times. can't think of any word at the moment. But for public speaking i practice any polysyllabic word and once I get it I have it for ever. If I make a mistake I take the opportunity to be a living example to understanding that aspect of SL difficulty experienced by dyslexics.
Jess I do try some of your pedagogy as differentation forms, it always create interest with and learning is always remembered. Some with speech difficulty welcome the opportunity to communicate in other ways.
I knew but never put it in perspective that turn taking is a form of communication. I do look forward to learning lots in these discussions Hya

I am ready to learning more

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 18, 2009 02:49 PM
first may I appologize for the repeated replies. I must have gone button happy. Hyacinth, I am very interested in your struggle with polysyllabic words. I am not so familiar with the term. Could you explain what you mean, please. I would love to learn more from you. You have a rich personal and profesional knowledge in dyslexia. I'd like to know more of what you've shared.

Dyslexia and phonology

Posted by rgreen2 at Jun 18, 2009 05:51 PM
Hi, Hyacinth, Good to speak to you yesterday all the way from the Virgin Isles. I hope it was helpful.
Your points about Dyslexia and your way of remembering your polysyllabic words is fascinating. I like the tip about time - often a very simple but effective message. I think that developing your own ways of remembering words is also one of the keys. I'd like to see your rehearsals.
 I spent several years working with pupils with Dyslexia and almost all had a background of Speech and Language difficulties. Equally pupils with early difficulties with phonological awareness will go on to struggle with spelling even when the underlying language difficulties have been resolved.
We can help by identifying as soon as possible those pupils who struggle to 'crack the code' of sounds /phonemes. Even in Reception class it is possible to identify those children who are not familiar with 'playing with sounds' and who will need additional support that can be delivered in a fun way at this early stage. Overlooking their needs then and rushing them on through the literacy curriculum is storing up problems ahead and unfortunately some of the most creative, children get lost then in 'underachievement'.

Ruth

Speech and Language Therapy

Posted by Lucie Cox at Jun 16, 2009 07:39 PM
Hi Jessica and Hyacinth,
Some interesting ideas in both your messages!

I often recommend that teachers try and back up spoken language with as much visual support as possible e.g: photos, pictures, gesture/sign.I also run training in schools looking at how teachers can implement in their classrooms.The emphasis being on that using visuals will support all children ans not just those with language and communication difficulties.
What experience have you both have of doing this in your classrooms/schools? How successful has this been as a whole school approach?

I am also interested in using movement in therapy and teaching e.g. getting in a box to teach the concept of 'in', using role play to practice social skills such as turn taking, starting conversations.

The issue of Dyslexia and Speech and Language Therapy is an interesting one. I think SLTs can support Literacy difficulties through Phonological Awareness activities e.g. rhyme, syllables, phomene games.

When you think about Speech and Language Therapy think 'Communication' and everything to do with that concept, and that is all potentially part of my job....

Lucie


Speech and Language Therapy

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 18, 2009 03:20 PM
Hi Lucy,
I found visuals, role play in conjunction with dramatice play, movement with own bodies or toys, stuffed animals, for any object of choice, etc.. to be quite successful with my students. Over time, they had taken ownership for their communication. Once demonstrated, then repeated, checked for understanding and aquistion, we would then move on to more accountability for communication. For example: for a kidergarten class we were reading a big book together (ten in a bed), first time I would model reading (maybe twice) then second time pause at a word kids have to call out what it is. I'd build on that. We'd then do a dramatization with ten kids on a mat (then I would elaborate that it is on nor under or over) and perform the book with continued association to the book. This lesson would continue on for maths, art, social studies, and so on. Literature we would write our own big book, or make cards using their hands as pattern to cut out the ten children on a bed and decorate each fingure with faces and so on. I try to use a whole language approach and holistic teaching. At that age, at least, I found it to be helpful.
I've been learning to incorporate signs and hand signals for communicating ideas and concepts at the special school I've been working in. I am so pleased to be learning more about that.
using sign language during instruction seemed to help many on the autistic and SLT students we have in the class. I do remember that sign language was a great communicating tool for my Downs sydrome daughter during her early years. The use of hands for communication is great. I guess the Italians with the use of their hands are quite the communicators :o)

Jess

Lovely ideas

Posted by rgreen2 at Jun 18, 2009 05:35 PM
Hi Jessica, These are really lovely ideas to reinforce those basic concept words which many children often find so difficult ( especially pupils with ASD) because they are relational and therefore the meaning is not fixed. Visual clues can help and are often the first things teachers put in place but using as many sensory approaches as possible is great practice in encouraging language development. It gets a bit harder to incorporate this holistic work into the classroom as pupuils get older but still so essential. Anyone got any good ideas for those older pupils?
 Remember also that our interventions often make a difference to expressive language scores but that enabling improvement in childrens' receptive language( comprehension) is much more difficult. Maggie Johnson's work is really worth reading on enabling children to become more self aware of their own level of understanding and promoting an ethos in the classroom of daring to ask / seek confirmation. Try reading 'Helping Children to Hang on your Every word' on this whole area.

Ruth Green

Lovely ideas

Posted by Sima Rutherford at Jun 19, 2009 06:18 PM
Dear All,

Very interesting discussion. Unfortunately in the UK teachers are trying to do so much in a day that, if a child in reception has not learnt the sounds/phonemes some teachers will ingnore it and carry on to teach the rest of their plan for that day or they will be behind.

With older children to help them speack, we did a lot of drama. For example, I used to have them on the carpet, often at the end of the day. I would start by saying, once upon a time.... the next person had to add a sentece to this, and then it would go round. Sometimes our story used to become so exciting and interesting, that we would not hear the bell to go home!!

If a child couldn't think of a sentence immediately, then the person next to him or her would carry on. No fuss, and then we would go back to him or her. We learnt to be tolerant about that, and also their story. This helped them to think, to talk and be confident, because the story belonged to them all.

I agree with all of you that we should use as many sensory approaches for teaching as possible, using visual clues is very important, because children learn best in different ways. All children will benefit from it, especially children with learning difficulties. My pupils used to show 'T' with two fingers, and that meant they needed to use the toilet! (Sign language?)

It would be ideal if the teachers had enough time or energy to bring a box and go in the box, to teach 'in' and probably 'out'. I wish I was taught that way as I still have problems with 'Prepositions!'

Sima

    

Lovely ideas

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 22, 2009 11:44 AM
prepositions! I, too, have issues with them. Thank you, Sima, for sharing. It is reassuring to have mentor support and advice. Thank you.
Jessica

processing time

Posted by rgreen2 at Jun 23, 2009 03:48 AM
Thank you Sima for joining us again. I agree with you -just that one tip of providing a little extra time is so vital. The 'making adjustments'section of the SLCN Inclusion Development Plan is really good on this and hopefully if that document comes off the staffroom shelf and becomes part of everyday classroom practice in the next year then we may see more children able to contribute to class/ group discussion rather than being labelled as 'switched off' or 'naughty'.
However there are so many worthwhile initiatives for schools to take on.
Ruth

Lovely ideas

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 22, 2009 11:58 AM
thank you, Ruth, I am always encouraged to hear from you and your input. this book sounds good. I will check it out.
Thanks,
Jessica

Further ideas....

Posted by Lucie Cox at Jun 22, 2009 10:05 PM
Hi all,

I'm so happy that you all seem to be trying out all sorts of different ways of communicating with all your children! And that you really see how using these multi-sensory methods are going to benefit all the children.

On holistic and multi-sensory teaching - I have found in my travels around primary schools that the more a school are together on using this way of teaching the more effective it is and a school becomes a wonderful nuturing communication friendly environment, however I also know that the ability to achieve this differs from school to school for many reasons.....

The more that teachers and schools learn and understand about communication the better the children's experience of learning and social interaction will be.

The links also between language and behaviour are huge and well researched. I work with so many children who have initially been labelled as 'naughty' or 'aren't listening' or act out for 'no reason'. Usually after one observation in the classroom I can see the triggers to the 'behaviour problem' and it is usually down to how the children are being communicated with, the language being used (too much of it and too high level) and not enough other methods of communication being employed.

Some books/resources I would recommended are:
'Language for Thinking' - by Stephen Parsons and Anna Branagan - published by Speechmark - a wonderful resource around looking are pictures in a small group or as a whole class and talking about the pictures using differentiated question types (ideal for 3 to 7 year olds)
'Talkabout' by Alex Kelly - a resource about Social skills - good for all primary aged children, especially older children.
'An irresistible urge to learn' resources - not sure of author, etc.

Phonological awareness - Maggie Johnson has lots on this.

Lucie.

Further ideas....

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 28, 2009 09:38 PM
Thank you for the book recommendations, Lucy. The link with bahaviour and language is quite interesting.
Jes

Further ideas....

Posted by Christiana Kefala at Jul 01, 2009 11:30 PM
Hello Lucie. Sorry to have stayed out of the conversation for so long but i ve been out of the country and not so keen to sit in front of a computer I have to admit! Anyhow, the whole conversation has been very interesting. My experience with speech and communication problems is a little different. I work in an international school in Greece where English is the main language taught and spoken although 80% of our children speak and understand very basic english. With that said, their problems might not be down to speech and communication disabilities but they still get very frustrated with it and act out on their frustration causing them to fail academically. Fortunatelly or unfortunatelly (not sure yet) we are not allowed to explain in Greek (cause that would mean that children from other countries wont understand what is being said and might feel excluded!) and therefore most teacher will try to mimic and use hand gestures to get their point across. How would you 'classify' this type of difficulty? Is it fair to assume these children have a speech and language difficulty given that if they were placed in a greek speaking school they would probably have no problem whatsoever?

Further ideas....

Posted by rgreen2 at Jul 02, 2009 01:37 PM
Dear Christiana, In the UK we would make a very clear distinction between children with English as an additional language and children with SLCN. The chuldren would idealy be assessed in their first language as well as in English in order to ascertain whether the difficulty is purely one of a second langague nature. as you can imagine, its not always simple to separate out the two.
Ruth

polysyllabic words

Posted by marion craven at Jun 23, 2009 09:31 PM
Hi
This discussion has moved on pretty quickly - can I go back to polysyllabic words. Currently I am (and the SENCo) in dispute with the literacy co- ordinator with regards to phonics, in particular the synthetic phonic programme THRASS. He feels that children should learn by this approach alone. However I feel that children especially dyslexics should learn by whatever approach suits them. Currently I teach using a highly structured multisensory phonic approach - i.e. synthetic. But I also teach syllables, and onset and rime because I personally know that learning to spell and read polysyllabic words is really difficult. By breaking down words into mangageable chunks enables children to have the confidence to have ago. But this goes against his synthetic principles and is causing quite a rift in our school, and although the teachers know my approach gets very good results (which have failed by his approach) they can not be seen to support it in class otherwise they are going against the literacy policy!
Any advice??

Comments for Marion

Posted by Lucie Cox at Jun 25, 2009 11:51 PM
Hi Marion,

What does your headteacher say about this?

From a speech and language therapy point of view I would agree with you in that a range of approaches will include all the children regardless of their learning needs.

Children with speech sound difficulties always benefit from phonological awareness work/approach (e.g. onset and rime, syllables) -alongside a speech sound programme.

I would also say children with language difficulties would benefit from a mixed approach.

As you will know there are huge links between language and literacy. For example word boundaries: when reading children need to be aware that there are both parts to words (syllables) and parts to a sentence (the words) when they read a sentence, this knowledge will help them to decode the meaning of the sentence.

Hope that helps.

Lucie.

Comments for Marion

Posted by marion craven at Jun 26, 2009 05:55 PM
Hi Lucie,

Thank you for your reassurance.

Last year this teacher bullied me regarding the work I do, and I reported it to my head. I have reported these incidents again and she said to send him to her if it happens again. She seems to agree with my thinking in front of me, but I am not sure if she leads from the top. You come to question your own understanding - which although sometimes can be a good thing, the whole situation is very intimidating.

Sorry, back to speech and language - in september I have been asked to do writing workshop with a small group of year 3 children with SEN. The class teacher said to give them opportunities to write and another said work sheets. But I am looking forward to discussing and making our own books. I feel that many children do not get the opportunity to talk about words and writing, and it can be very exciting.
When I was a infant teacher most of my literacy time was about making books in groups/partners and by the end of the year the deputy said my bottom group was further ahead in (narrative) writing than the top group in the other class, but most of all my class wanted to write and share their ideas. Talking has much to answer for.

Thanks again - I don't think much will change, at least I know I am right.
 
Marion

Hi Every one

Posted by Hyacinth Rose-Manners at Jun 28, 2009 01:30 AM
Was out of it for awhile My life could be a callaloo at times. I just have not been able to settle down to my study time. But!!!! Always happy to be part of these exchanges I learn so much Thanks
 
Yes Ruth great talking with you and Pauline thanks.
Well with the pollysyllabic words Jess asked words with more than two syllables. Many children I teach are afraid of those big words they will say. So the game is see how many small words we can find in these pollysyllabic words ( big words) simple example together has her/ to/ get. any order the student gives it. Then I say you can read it big words are made up of many small words. So say the small words faster faster without a break in the word. Then they all excited says "together or I know it" we work it out we never forget it. Some times they pronounce a word so strange to/get/her instead of to/ge/ther Exception to rule where g followed by e says /j/ sound. Then the ethos of the class is of such that they can laugh at them selves Example machine pronounced as ma/shine laughter. I then read it in the sentence laugh then correction.
I do have to work out some myself quietly because their difficulty is mine. always teach new words in context if you want to assist us.

I read the word to my husband and he corrects me if needed. he says you missed a syllable I then count the syllables following the rule for every vowel it is a syllable except the "e" at the end. and I know suffixes. So I teach the students as I will figure it out myself. but have them figure it out.
Yes pictures/ visual aids are so encouraging. rhyming ohh there are so many games I use onset and rime important.
I have to reassure parents so often 10 year old or older it is ok for them to to read a book with picyures, they will graduate themselves from pictures.
Marion a range of approaches is what we need sometimes I learn with one style another time I need another.
Yes writing book are the greatest the self esteem to the student escalates Write for them their story verbatim, they are able to read it for themselves. They get excited I have heard the comment by students " that is what the word chair looks like" So they see a name and says " that is how I see my aunty write her name.
after a time they can then recognise their words in other writings, we can then look at syntax and semantics. But like Marion I am told by the head teacher that the student's workbook shows incompetence of the teacher with syntax and semantics incorrect. Parent conferences can explain that.

Well I had difficulties learning to read and spell maths was my prize but now I love teaching reading and speech and language because in learning to teach it I have taught myself so much and is still teaching myself.

Comments for Marion

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Jun 28, 2009 09:44 PM
I agree with you all. Let your counterpart, marion, remember multiple intelligences. Their is room for a range of approaches to cater to the need of the student and how they learn.

Narrative

Posted by Lucie Cox at Jul 01, 2009 10:50 PM
Hi Marion and all,

If you know why you are doing something (are sure of your rationales) and are passionate about it, then at some point you will win through!

I love your insights into Dyslexia Hyacinth.

About narrative. Working on narrative is one of my favourite ways of working. It can encompass and develop so many areas e.g. vocabulary, sentence structure, connectives, WH questions (what, who, when, why, etc) and also work on the social aspect of sharing stories and ideas.

I love the idea of making books.

Lucie.

Narrative

Posted by rgreen2 at Jul 02, 2009 01:45 PM
Hi all, I agree with Lucie about the great benefits of working with narrative. I have a nice training pack on the stages of narrative development in children and how to promote/ extend. I could perhaps post it up on the web site if people are interested.
I have always had a lot of success in the past using narrative with children and teenagers who were struggling to learn to read. One girl learnt to read through developing a story about Tina Turner, her favourite singer and someone she related to very much. It came at a stage when all the usual reading books had been rejected and really motivated her. At 15 she finally became a 'reader'.
All best,
Ruth

Narrative

Posted by marion craven at Jul 02, 2009 07:19 PM
Hi Ruth,

Yes please!

Marion

thank you everyone

Posted by marion craven at Jul 02, 2009 04:09 PM
Hi,

My SENCo and Deputy Head have told the literacy coordinator that with SEN children they should have any that works including a range of approaches and backed what I am doing! He has returned to me and said although he doesn't agree, and the Rose Report referred to the fact it was damaging to do more than one approach, we can do as we like!!!!!!!!!

Marion




damaging more than one approach

Posted by Hyacinth Rose-Manners at Jul 02, 2009 08:32 PM
Rose Report I suppose is based on empirical research, but I have seen from my experience with teaching, that a range of approaches like Ruth said with the 15 year old (she must have experienced many approaches before) writing her book worked. To me a range of approaches is like differentation teaching. We have a class of students with learning differences so we need different approaches. What may work for you may not work for another or what worked for you today may not work for him tomorrow, because of a variable today. you must leave space for error. What is it called again in ensuring a test is reliable. Yes here I go again " measurement of error". But by trying different approaches he / she will settle with one eventually.

Phonics and Narrative

Posted by Lucie Cox at Jul 02, 2009 11:32 PM
Well done Marion!

The Rose Review does place huge emphasis on the teaching of 'synthetic phonics' however it does also say that this teaching method should be built on the foundations of phonological awareness skills (e.g. onset and rime, syllables, etc).

Another good Narrative resource is 'Black Sheep' narrative resource. 'Black Sheep' publications produce many other therapy and learning materials too.

I have enjoyed being part your discussions, thankyou all.
Thankyou for inviting me into the discussion Ruth!

I wish you all very good luck in all your teaching and learning.

Yours Lucie.